Dune: Part Two

2024

★★★½ Liked

Dune Part Two makes the pieces click together. I did watch this in Paris with French subtitles including the Fremon bits, and my French isn’t great - but it’s still solid enough and I’ve read the books to be able to pick up on the context I was missing. And it helps Villeneuve is a master visualist. 

Maybe the most I’ve enjoyed a Dune thing having DNF the series at Book 4? It’s hard not to ire a Big, grand sci-fi that’s faithful right the way through - but that carries across the novel’s weaknesses and it can often feel slow, sluggish - and lacks the emotional depth it needs to really feel like a classic. There’s nothing Frodo/Sam level here of emotional drama and that rendered the grand final act felt a bit cold, empty and boring. Some of the cast are spectacular but its all star collection of names is very much hit and miss, I didn’t buy the Emperor - Walken felt poor and Pugh felt a bit disted - even Zendaya unconvincing. Chalamet at his strongest - much improved over part one.

Never thought I’d say this but David Goyer pulls off an adaption of Foundation better than Villeneuve of Dune.

Block or Report

Milo liked these reviews

All