Punks, Drunks and Love: on shelves and screens this month

The ultimate alcoholic hang-out comedy, Withnail & I (1987) arrives on 4K.
The ultimate alcoholic hang-out comedy, Withnail & I (1987) arrives on 4K.

A brand new label on the circuit, a classic for the boozers, Robert De Niro and Meryl Streep falling in love, French cannibalism and the ultimate date movie for goths all feature in the latest edition of Shelf Life.

As I’ve noted before, each month a theme emerges as I’m writing this column. For May of 2025, there’s a striking and somewhat upsetting contrast between the tender green buds that are growing on the tree outside my window and the dark, destructive urges that guide the characters in this month’s picks.

Some are more literal than others: In My Skin turns self-harm into grotesque body horror, while Going Down and Withnail & I numb themselves with drugs and booze. Falling in Love takes the most mature approach, but an extramarital affair—even a fleeting, accidental one—always suggests dissatisfaction. And The Iron Rose fills the air with the scent of graveyard dirt. Maybe I’ll go take a walk in the cemetery later…

Going Down

4K restoration in theaters starting May 9 from Muscle Distribution.

Going Down

Going Down 1983

I’ve name-checked film programmer and historian Elizabeth Purchell in this column more than once. But this time is especially exciting, as she announces the launch of her own label, Muscle Distribution. Named for the gay Japanese classic, Muscle promises a “heavy focus on radical, canon-expanding repertory cinema”. And if you’re familiar with Liz’s programming work, you know that she’s got the knowledge to back that up.

Muscle’s inaugural release, the Aussie cult classic Going Down, premieres at the Brooklyn Academy of Music on May 9, with a nationwide theatrical tour to follow. And it’s very much in line with the label’s mission, combining the best aspects of better-known punk films with a glimpse into a time and place I hadn’t considered before: the early-’80s Sydney punk scene. Jrhovind describes the characters—most of whom are struggling to survive day-to-day—and their hard-partying world as “something like Seidelman by way of BBC-era Leigh”, with a touch of The Decline of Western Civilization through documentary-style footage of local bands. The soundtrack is a ripper as well, with tracks from a pre-Disneyfied Randy Newman and The Birthday Party, featuring a young Nick Cave.

One thing that strikes me about this movie is that, although it was directed by a man, its portrayal of young female characters feels authentic and honest, particularly when it comes to self-destruction and survival sex work. (Two of the female leads co-wrote the screenplay, which probably has a lot to do with that.) On the whole, Going Down feels very handmade, with “the urgency and go-for-broke energy” that Orson says he “like[s] to see in a debut film”.

Add some inexplicable slapstick comedy from a handsome nerd on roller skates who’s also the default romantic lead, and you have a singular launch for what’s sure to be a singular label. Only 163 have logged Going Down on Letterboxd as of this writing, so now’s your chance to get in on a new cult classic.

Withnail & I

4K UHD and Blu-ray available May 20 from The Criterion Collection.

Withnail & I

Withnail & I 1987

Speaking of the debauchery and aimlessness of youth: Withnail & I gets grosser with each subsequent upgrade, and I mean that as a compliment. Megan evocatively describes Bruce Robinson’s sodden alcoholic hang-out comedy as “a wet washcloth.” Indeed, the characters look more like the Ralph Stean caricatures on the film’s poster than ever in a 4K restoration supervised by DP Peter Hannan that’s hitting disc this month from Criterion after debuting last year from Arrow Video UK.

The obvious touchstone here is Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, given that both movies feature off-the-rails travel narratives and heavy substance abuse. (The Stean connection also helps.) But Cait has an interesting take, emphasizing the toxic bromance by comparing it to Elaine May’s Mikey and Nicky. “Absolutely rancid film, but oh my God I loved it,” she writes, building on the “wet dog and cheap wine” scentscape evoked above.

The by-then-stale fumes of the ’60s counterculture cling to our characters (Withnail & I is set in 1969), as does the decrepit British aristocracy. They combine in Richard E. Grant’s Withnail, the degenerate scion of a posh family who talks like a Miltonian gentleman and obeys every whim of his debauched id. Grant “absolutely dominates every scene he takes part in, even the ones where he is relatively quiet,” Steven writes. It’s a tour-de-force performance, enhanced by the film’s “trading-card collection of deathless quotes, built for you to bark out at each other as you reach the end of the second bottle of wine,” as Graham describes the dialogue.

“Robinson has done some fine work before [and] after, but this is the kind of unique bottling of a time, world and mood that only happens once in a career,” Graham continues. Although he’s been in dozens of movies since then, Withnail continues to follow Grant around as well: a famous non-imbiber, he was nominated for an Oscar for another alcoholic role in 2018’s Can You Ever Forgive Me?

Falling in Love

Blu-ray available May 6 from Fun City Editions.

Falling in Love

Falling in Love 1984

Withnail & I ends on a sobering, poignant note. Falling in Love starts there and stays there, telling a subtle, sensitive story about, as Lili puts it, “what it is to fall in love with someone when it’s possibly the least convenient or acceptable thing to do.” The romance between Molly (Meryl Streep) and Frank (Robert De Niro) is complicated. It’s forbidden. Both of them are married to other people, and one of them has young children at home. But, despite both of their efforts, it keeps growing until they can’t deny it anymore.

This ’80s-set update on Brief Encounter is one of those mature adult dramas about mature adult things that are endangered in today’s cinema landscape—chicken in a glass box playing tic-tac-toe excepted. That touch of a country carnival in the middle of Manhattan is a bizarre exception to the film’s otherwise sophisticated urban backdrop, all upscale shopping at grand old department stores and Christmases in Connecticut by a roaring fire. Director Ulu Grosbard even makes commuting to the suburbs look glamorous, turning regional transit into a site for romance.

Even more so than the setting, however, the performances are the star. “The chemistry between De Niro and Streep is insane,” Mission Enjoyment writes. “Meryl Streep has such a glowing, old Hollywood look to her that is just stunning.” Streep gets the majority of the film’s monologues and big moments, but as Matt notes, “it’s possibly De Niro’s most considered, delicate performance” as well.

Some take issue with Falling In Love’s pro-adultery storyline, but I’d argue that’s just part of the film’s maturity: things like this just happen sometimes, and when they do, they’re nobody’s fault. That’s what’s so bittersweet about them. Our managing editor Mitchell Beaupre is a fan, penning a booklet essay for the film’s worldwide Blu-ray debut via Fun City Editions.

The Iron Rose

4K UHD available May 25 from Indicator.

The Iron Rose

The Iron Rose 1973

La Rose de fer

This rare non-vampiric outing from Euro-horror master Jean Rollin is also the ultimate date movie for goths, making the “sex = death” connection in a more romantic, more chthonic way than your typical slasher movie. It’s more of an OG “Mary Shelley losing her virginity on her mother’s grave” type of thing, a hypnotic work of intuitive, dreamlike surrealism whose plot is simple but whose implications are profound. Jennifer writes that The Iron Rose “possesses all the eroticism and melancholia characteristic of [Rollin’s] other work, but this one is stripped back to the bare essentials and is the better for it.”

These elemental characters—they’re referred to in the credits as simply “The Girl” and “The Boy”—descend into a catacomb to make love, and emerge into the world of the dead. The fence no longer has a gate—multiple compare The Iron Rose to Luis Buñuel and The Exterminating Angel—and the girl is transformed, “wiser and scarier than her years should allow,” as Kai writes. They’re accompanied by a series of evocative, deeply weird archetypes, including a man in a vampire cape (Rollin just can’t help himself) and, even stranger, a clown.

It all means something, probably. But this is primarily a mood piece, a reflection on the fragility of youth next to the dusty permanence of death. Rollin took advantage of being based in Europe, where cities are literally built on skeletons, throughout his career: here, Brian writes that he “knows to trust in his location, the overwhelmingly atmospheric Madeline Cemetery, and in the quasi-Bressonian charisma of his actors… drawing indescribably potent sensations from fairly modest means and glossed with a peculiarly Gallic erotic-thanatoic gloom”.

That gloom—and the harsh spotlights on moss-covered tombs—will look especially striking in 4K, as The Iron Rose hits disc as part of UK label Indicator’s series of deluxe Rollin restorations. I have the label’s Fascination release, and it’s gorgeous; I can’t wait to pick this one up as well.

In My Skin

4K UHD and Blu-ray available May 27 from Severin Films.

In My Skin

In My Skin 2002

Dans ma peau

Sex, death and surrealism take on a sickening new form in In My Skin, a truly transgressive work of body horror from ’s Marina de Van. Released in 2002, it’s part of the “New French Extremity,” an unwieldy collection of films that encomes everything from the provocative eroticism of Catherine Breillat to straight-up torture porn. This one is for the Trouble Every Day girlies, although its violent urges are directed inward instead of outward: de Van’s picture captures the overwhelming pressure and dissociative release of self-harm, escalating from picking at scabs to full-on auto-cannibalism.

De Van casts herself as the film’s lead, either because of her personal connection to the material or because she couldn’t ask anyone else to do what was required for the role. Maybe a bit of both. Regardless, Esther (de Van) is moving in with her boyfriend and just got promoted at work; she should be happy, but her need to self-mutilate grows stronger with every milestone she achieves. “Marina de Van is doing for ‘women’s liberation’ as coercion into the capitalist machine… as Chantal Akerman does for the nightmare of domestic incarceration,” Jacqueline explains. Asked why she’s doing this by her upset, confused partner, Esther shrugs it off. To her, hurting herself is the most natural thing in the world.

The gore of In My Skin is incredibly disturbing, especially the way that it sounds. So it may seem counterintuitive that Letterboxd describe it as a comfort movie: “I see so much of myself in Esther, and the struggles this movie portrays about identity and the body,” Luz writes. “This movie has become a source of comfort for whenever I am grappling with my own identities, not in spite of its extremity, but because of it.” Alis agrees, writing, “I have never been so viscerally disgusted, identified with a character, felt seen, heartbroken, vindicated, and impressed.” The key word is “seen,” I think: the emotions on display here are extremely painful and difficult to discuss, but they’re also very real.

A restoration of In My Skin has been floating around for a few years now: It screened at the Fantasia Film Festival in 2022 as part of a series celebrating the re-release of Kier-La Janisse’s landmark House of Psychotic Women. It’s been difficult to see outside of festivals up to this point, but that changes this month with its worldwide Blu-ray debut from Severin Films. If the rarity isn’t enough to hook you, the special features include a murderer’s row of cool horror-film women, including Janisse, Fantasia programmer Justine Smith, Rue Morgue editor Andrea Subissati and the prolific, brilliant Alexandra Heller-Nicholas.

Further Reading

Tags

Share This Article