Summer Daze: Annie Baker and Julianne Nicholson take us to the inner world of Janet Planet

Julianne Nicholson and Zoe Ziegler as mother and daughter in Janet Planet.
Julianne Nicholson and Zoe Ziegler as mother and daughter in Janet Planet.

With her directorial feature debut Janet Planet now in theaters, Pulitzer Prize-winning writer-director Annie Baker and star Julianne Nicholson reflect with Adesola Thomas about the childhood nostalgia of hazy Massachusetts summers.

That’s the best, when you’re in dialogue with someone and you’re like, ‘We’re not going to hurt each other’s feelings. We are going to try everything and we will be honest when it’s not working and nobody will be offended.’ That’s when you can really be creative.

—⁠Annie Baker

If you were often outdoors as a child in the summers, you likely a series of keen sensations: having your palms licked by blades of grass, the soft scrape of tree bark against flesh, sinking fingers into soil. Memories of aimless warm days in July might conjure a sense of unblemished bliss. But in Janet Planet, Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright Annie Baker’s 1991-set debut feature film, these lilting moments are complicated with one child’s formative, tender bummer summer.

Months before beginning middle school, eleven-year-old Lacy (Zoe Ziegler) saunters in the belly of the Massachusetts wood and becomes acquainted with notions of loneliness and departure, with and without the help of her acupuncturist mother, Janet (Julianne Nicholson).

Throughout Janet Planet, Janet welcomes adults into her home, expanding and closing space between herself and Lacy in the process. There’s Wayne (Will Patton), an iron-wired male partner, Regina (Sophie Okonedo), an old friend and devout theater hippie, and Avi (Elias Koteas), a charismatic leader in Regina’s New England theater scene.

Lacy practices piano under her mother’s gaze.
Lacy practices piano under her mother’s gaze.

Baker filmed this triptych of visitors and their respective acts in sequence. “We did shoot, not in scene order, but in act order,” she tells me. “We shot the Wayne section, then the Regina section, then the Avi section with little overlaps. That’s what made sense in this schedule and with the actor schedules, but it was also fun, and actually really productive to meet the characters in order, especially for Zoe and Julianne.”

Nicholson concurs, “It was so lucky that we were able to film in that way, actually. It’s not always the case where you can film in somewhat a sequential order as the story’s being told. And it shifts because we shift depending on who we’re with—who’s the important person in our life or who’s even in the room—dynamics change. All three of those people are wonderful wackos, and I hope to include myself and Zoe in that same category… To be with each of those people as those characters was just pure pleasure.”

As refreshing as it is to see Janet in her element (her own planet) and individuality beyond her obligation to Lacy as a mother, Baker also invites us into Lacy’s loneliness: for example, she tends to a band of homemade salt-and-pepper shaker dolls that she clothes, speaks to and tucks into bed at night. As she witnesses her mother experience emotional intimacy with friends and lovers that come and go, Lacy comes to understand that her mother does not belong only to her, that she’s an imperfect person out in the world. Only in films like Whale Rider and Where the Wild Things Are have I seen the childhood anxieties, feelings of alienation and ardor for places be visually legitimized with such care and permission.

Lacy (relatably) spends a lot of the film lying despondently on the ground.
Lacy (relatably) spends a lot of the film lying despondently on the ground.

Therein evokes a curiosity and sense of danger for Lacy that complicates and matures her away from the simple innocence of childhood. In a piercing moment, Janet tells Lacy that she’s “always had this knowledge that she could make any man fall in love with her if [she] really tried” and that “[she] thinks maybe it’s ruined her life.” It’s the sort of electrifying ission that characterizes Janet’s expansive inner world, but also invites you to wonder what it means to confide or reveal such a thing to your child.

Nicholson comments on Janet’s blurry emotional territory: “It’s very murky in there. What’s the right thing to share? What’s the right thing to hold back? I’ve said a few times, too, I feel like parenting in 1991 looks different than parenting now.”

Letterboxd member David writes in his review, “I knew Annie would be able to bring her pregnant pauses and perfect, understated characterizations to the screen. I just didn’t know she’d also be able to capture exactly how the air feels and sounds in late August.” Avalyn comments, “The scene where Janet starts talking about how she wonders if Lacy will grow up to be a lesbian scared me so much, as if the film had been listening in on my thoughts for years. But it’s not an act of deception, a trick to shock me. It’s an electric charge in the characters, conduits for the cosmos.”

Sound designer Paul Hsu completed more than 100 hours of field recordings to craft the sonic personality of Lacy and Janet’s forested universe. Baker and her director of photography Maria von Hausswolff revisited films like Éric Rohmer’s The Green Ray, Apichatpong Weerasethakul’s Tropical Malady and Ingmar Bergman’s melding female psyches like Persona and Autumn Sonata.

I spoke with Baker about these creative collaborations, childhood and the power of place in Janet Planet.

Annie Baker directs a scene on the set of Janet Planet.
Annie Baker directs a scene on the set of Janet Planet.

What fascinates you about mother-daughter stories? Are there mother-daughter stories either on the stage or on-screen that you really love, that really frustrate you, any that you have big emotions about?
Annie Baker
: I wouldn’t describe myself as interested in mother-daughter stories, per se. I am the daughter of a mother and the mother of a daughter, and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that I started writing this movie after I had a daughter, but also it wasn’t a conscious choice. I’m trying to think of my favorite mother-daughter story. No one’s asked me that. That’s such an interesting question. I really liked Furiosa. I can’t say it was an influence on Janet Planet since I saw it last weekend, but I’m a big fan. I’m a big fan. Furiosa, retrospectively influential on Janet Planet.

There’s a way Bergman photographs and thinks about motherhood and relationships just between female relatives, period, between sisters, too. And there’s a kind of sensuality, there’s a kind of eroticism to the closeness between mothers and daughters and between sisters and between friends that I think he gets at that I definitely talked about with my DP [Maria von Hausswolff].

What conversations did you have with Zoe about Lacy’s relationship to place and to her mother, if any?
I learned very quickly to not try to describe the character too much to Zoe, which is not to say she’s the same person or even that similar to this character, but I realized very quickly that she understood the material in a bordering on telepathic way. If I got overly psychological about it or overly analytical, I would ruin her performance. So we did not talk about the character at all; if I tried to, I saw it go wrong very quickly. She learned the lines. She showed up, she listened—which is everything—obviously she reacted…

There was a lot of choreography. She’d never been in front of a camera before. In of her body and her head movements and how many times she blinked, we really had to figure a lot of the technicalities of that out. But psychology-wise, she was in her own private psychological universe, which was, looking back, as it should be, for that character.

Lacy beats the heat in one of her trademark oversized T-shirts.
Lacy beats the heat in one of her trademark oversized T-shirts.

How long had Lacy’s line, “Every day of my life is hell,” been a part of the story? When I saw Janet Planet at NYFF, it evoked the most exciting reaction in the room that day.
I know, I was really surprised! You just never know. This happens with theater, too, when you’re making something: what will make people vocally react [to], there’s just no predicting it. I was very surprised that people had such a reaction to that line. It was even [in] the first draft, definitely.

I feel like kids say things like that all the time, or I did. My daughter says very dramatic things all the time, and it was really important to me that the characters say it with a kind of levity, because I feel like 99 percent of child actors, if you ask them to say that line, will say it with an enormous amount of drama and pathos, and the way Zoe said that line—and I think we worked on it a little—it’s just an observation. She’s just making a light observation.

Can you speak more about working with Sophie Okonedo?
Sophie’s one of my favorite actors that I’ve ever worked with. She’s such a theater animal, too; we’ve both spent so much time in rehearsal rooms. It was actually amazing when she came to set, because there was a funny, fast and furious, witty way she likes working that feels just like spitballing in a rehearsal room together. She’s very intellectual. It was through philosophical jokes about and around the character that we found the performance together, and she’s very not precious. This is also one of my favorite things about her, and I learned a lot from working with her: if I gave her a note that she didn’t like, she would just really politely be like, “I don’t like that note. Can you give me another?”

I feel with other actors, you give them a bad note and you feel them freeze up and you have to backtrack or they don’t tell you… There was a clear, unforced, really transparent way she works that was, oh, my God, so, so fun. It felt like we could try really stupid stuff together and be honest with each other. I could just be like, “Sophie, it’s not working,” or she could be like, “Annie, it’s not working.” That’s the best, when you’re in dialogue with someone and you’re like, “We’re not going to hurt each other’s feelings. We are going to try everything and we will be honest when it’s not working and nobody will be offended.” That’s when you can really be creative. I would love to work with her again.

She also has done outdoor hippie theater performances, [and] was part of a hippie theater company in her youth, so she just came right into that theater company and knew exactly what she was doing and could inhabit that world so effortlessly—both the world of subtle film performance and the world of wild projecting—so 200 people can hear you outside, kind of like theater acting.

Sophie Okenedo and Baker collaborate on set.
Sophie Okenedo and Baker collaborate on set.

There’s a moment in the film where we hear Lacy’s watching Clarissa Explains It All. I wonder, are there albums, shows, art that come to mind when you recall your own upbringing in 1990s Massachusetts?
What a good question. Nickelodeon, definitely. Nickelodeon when you’re nauseous feels really important to me: the kind of TV you watch when you’re sick, when you’re a kid. The sounds of nature in western Massachusetts are a part of me, are the score for this movie.

New England theater tradition was very big in my childhood, and I wanted to pay tribute to it in this movie, and that I associate with no other part of the world other than Massachusetts and Vermont. Grape-Nuts were really important to me, to have the crunching of Grape-Nuts in the movie. The moment where your parent opens the letter from the school and you find out who your teacher’s going to be next year, it really is a big deal, actually. I that your fate is decided and a year is so epic when you’re eleven, and finding out who your sixth-grade teacher is going to be is huge. It’s everything, that moment.

And I think the moments where you see someone for the last time and then years later are like, “Oh, my God, that was the [last time]…” There’s that moment when Sophie Okonedo gets into the van with Elias Koteas and you sort of know that’s the last time [Lacy]’s ever going to see her. There’s a bunch of them throughout the movie, these unceremonious accidental goodbyes that happened throughout our lives are a big part of, for me, ing that time of my life.

What do you want to make next?
I love that question. I’m actually really excited about the thing I’m making next. I just finished two weeks ago, the first draft for a screenplay for my next movie, which is just for two actors. It’s very different, and I’m thinking about it all the time and enjoying taking everything I learned from making Janet Planet and putting it towards this new project. It’s very pleasurable to feel like I understand the medium a little bit better.


Janet Planet’ is now playing in US theaters, courtesy of A24.

Further Reading

Tags

Share This Article