this is more of a historical document than a movie.  of this series that i adore, this has always been the one that i’ve avoided and the one i think i enjoy watching the least.

the prequels, Obi-Wan, Andor, and Rogue One each give some new weight to this paper-thin story, but i still can’t ever surrender to it, the way i can to every other piece of this franchise.  i appreciate it, Marcia Lucas’ editing saves the story, i…

incredible. viscerally beautiful. i sobbed for most of the movie.

biggest crime is the PS2 graphics (like every other blockbuster now), and the lack of stakes in the performances in act 3.  otherwise, this is achingly sweet and well-made.  it also feels like it was written by Roald Dahl in a way that neither of the other two adaptations totally tap into.

if we’re going to keep rebooting old IP forever, i think this movie is a landmark achievement in sincerity.…

banger. knockout. obvious. pop canon. one of those things that feels like it’s always existed. Ryan Coogler believes in the power of film, and he's cracked how to make a crowd-pleaser without sacrificing any integrity. this cast is on fire — handily the best performances by all of the MCU actors that Coogler pulled over (Wunmi Mosaku especially, oh my GOD). perfectly written, shot beautifully, fresh, fun, and fast.

everybody gushing is telling you the truth, especially about the musical…