The most cinematic Hallmark movie I've seen.

Masterpiece!

It does a great job of getting you invested in all the characters and the nuances of moving forward while providing some great thrills along the way.

I liked the concept of following the events of '77, with the Son of Sam murders being the sense of dread in the background of everyone's minds, but the execution of the story just didn't work. It felt like the film didn't know what it wanted to be and tried to mix poorly certain vibes through the film's score in scenes that didn't mesh, which made it jarring and took away from getting into the story.